Three Lives of Butter
by Sarp Sozdinler, Netherlands
She began with the shallots, five small ones, dry and copper-skinned, nested in a bowl like bird eggs. She peeled them without looking, thumbs working automatically, the way her mother once kneaded dough. Their scent, raw and astringent, bit the air. It pulled her, instantly, back to the narrow kitchen of her childhood home, where the windows fogged even in summer and the counters smelled faintly of yeast and lemon rind. Her mother moved through the space with a weary grace, never quite hurried but never still, the hem of her apron stained and damp, her fingers always dusted with flour or salt. The stove clicked and buzzed, alive with something more than the fire within. It was in that kitchen, between the sound of chopping and the smell of simmering, that she first understood even silence could hum.
The knife moved fluidly between her fingers. Halved, then sliced to ribbons, the shallots fell like confetti into the shallow pot, where the unsalted cubes of butter hissed their slow melt. She watched them change states: solid to liquid, yellow to gold. The small transformations, never failing to amaze her. Her grandmother used to say that butter had three lives, and each one told the cook another story. The first life was childhood. The second, growth. She remembered her mother scraping softened butter into a dish, smoothing it flat, dead, carving a cross through it.
“In case the devil’s hungry,” she’d say, smiling without mirth.
She added the shallots, and the kitchen bloomed warm. Then saffron: four threads, dropped in like little bombs. Their red deepened immediately, melting into the butter’s golden domain, staining it orange, then amber, then something in between. The scent was precise and elusive. Familiar. Bringing back memories of a summer thunder just outside a Ridgeway attic, curtains half-drawn. A house with high ceilings and terrible heat. The man her mother lived with—quiet, distant, impossibly cruel to animals—kept saffron in a silver tin he never actually used. “It’s not for eating,” he told her once, without revealing what it was for. She and her mother burned through themselves within a year and a half in the crudeness of that house. She’d left one night while the couple slept in the next room, her shoes in her hand, the hallway cool and endless like the road ahead.
The mussels were waiting in a metal colander, dark and closed like secrets. She cleaned them one at a time, thumbs pressing into ridges, fingers dislodging the mushy beards. The water ran cold, numbing. The smell was of a beach at dusk, her father showing her how to lift stones without disturbing what lived underneath. “Turn it gently,” he said, grabbing one to demonstrate, under which crabs scattered into shadows. “Always give them a fighting chance.” She’d pocketed the smoothest stone and named it Seal—her first act of authorship. When she left home for college, she forgot the tin can she kept her stones in under the bed. When she returned, her mother had thrown it out, its absence outlined by a dent on the rug.
She poured white wine into the pot. Just enough to lift the browned shallots, to pull the saffron up from the bottom. The wine hissed when it hit the hot surface, sudden and bright, and with a sound that startled her, like breaking something she hadn’t meant to touch. Once, in Brooklyn, she broke a wineglass that triggered a series of events. She’d been blissfully avoiding any human interaction since she left home, soon to be excepted by a man she’d marry to escape the lair of loneliness she’d so carefully weaved. A friend of a friend’s rooftop party, the city wrapped in August heat. Him with his sunburned hands, reaching for her waist with a laugh too shrill it scratched at her ears. Despite his forthrightness and altogether awkward manners, she kissed him against a skylight, and it all clicked into place. He said her mouth tasted like citrus and sand, like a faraway land.
She tipped the mussels in, the X-factor that would graduate the dish from a mixture of ingredients into a meal. They landed like stones into water, all clatter and splash. She covered the pot, letting the past and present seal themselves together in that cramped space, tight as a lid. It would take minutes for them to reorient themselves. Maybe less.
In no time, the steam rose in plumes. The shells knocked against each other in a soft percussion. She turned the heat low, wiped her hands, and watched. The waiting was the hardest part. Her mother once said that the best meals are made waiting for something or someone that would alter the course of one’s life. She felt the truth of her wisdom now.
When she lifted the lid, the kitchen filled with a scent so complete, so wide and gold and briny, that she nearly closed her eyes to a teardrop. The mussels had opened their black coats to reveal tender ochre insides, curled and glistening, as if surprised to be seen. She tore fresh parsley with her fingers and let it fall like spring rain across the open shells. She ladled them into a shallow bowl, some broth too—sun-colored, touched with the mineral weight of the sea—and set it on the table, alongside the wicker basket that cradled the bread, alongside the fans of napkin, alongside the bottle of chianti.
When the doorbell rang, she did not stand up right away. She remained seated in her chair, watching, her reflection caught in the window’s darkening glass. Outside, the light had gone a strange, sickly color. Inside, the steam from the bowl curled upward like script, dissolving before it could be read. The mussels waited as if for their cue to pry their shells open, to tell their secrets, murmur the stories of faraway lands.
Sarp Sozdinler is a writer based in Philadelphia and Amsterdam. His writing has found places in Kenyon Review, Electric Literature, Shenandoah, Wigleaf, HAD, Flash Frog, Pithead Chapel, Fractured Lit, and Maudlin House, among other journals. His stories have been selected as finalists for the Los Angeles Review Short Fiction Prize and the Passages North Waasnode Short Fiction Prize. His work has been selected or nominated for several anthologies including the Pushcart Prize, Best Small Fictions, and Best Microfiction. He edits the literary journal The Bulb Region.